Wednesday, September 10, 2025

Guns or Butter. There's enough money for both. We only lack the political will.

 

Dr. Richard Denton of Sudbury, Ontario, Canada brought to my attention just days ago a British Medical Journal series stating that war/military is a social determinant of health.   Arms industry as a commercial determinant of health | The BMJ\  War is profitable to some, profoundly deadly to others, and most are not directly from violence. 

CONTEXT: If wars or even the fear of war persists there will always be a profiting arms industry.  Security (survival) is the first goal of every life form.  Thriving, the second, quickly follows.  Humankind has reached a point in our evolution where only half of us is thriving while our weapon systems are so powerful they could end civilization as we know it - or end our species.  Humankind must rapidly find a way to transform our current global governance and economic systems, or this spiral of chaos will continue to accelerate.  Most importantly – humankind must figure out quickly what we want most.   Temporary peace with profiting weapons investors or sustainably maximizing the health of people and the planet.   

Human flourishing must urgently become our collective priority.  But without a guarantee of security from wars the Arms industry will continue to flourish - while humankind will continue to lose nearly ten times more lives from infectious disease (new, remerging, or poverty related), extreme weather events/conditions, occasional natural disasters, and violent extremist movements (domestic and global) largely driven by real grievances or delusional religious beliefs – than from violent conflicts. Lethal conflicts are often driven by poverty, injustices, or extreme weather conditions. This series brings up the same old “Guns or Butter” logic.  There is no shortage of money in the world to do both.  Preventable deaths by both wars or a lack of funding on basic health needs happens even when there are no wars.  Both are the product of a lack of political will in world flush with dozens of trillions of dollars stashed in Off-shore and now Crypto currency.  If those with money want their lives and their families’ lives to be secure and to sustain nature’s systems which sustain us all, they urgently need to invest in stopping wars and in preventing them.  Prevention being the key word.  That is the foundation of health.  Our species’ wisest investment would be funding the UN Sustainable Development Goals ASAP. It may not stop all the wars, but it will prevent some - while addressing the root causes of violence, the greater killers linked to poverty and environmental destruction.  All while building resilience -- until we decide to transform our obviously flawed human engineered systems.   If we were a wise species, this should have been started on September 12, 2001.  Some were calling for it.  But those in power were happy with the UN status quo - ‘the law of force’ vs the force of law. 

The BMJ Series focuses on the arms industry as a commercial determinant of health and uncovers the role of the arms trade in health. It calls for more scrutiny of its health-harming activities and its unhealthy relationship with governments.

An international group of experts lay out the direct and wider harms of arms and show how weapons manufacturers use commercial strategies to subvert public health agendas and shape discourse around security and violence.

The Series argues that, like the tobacco, alcohol, and fossil fuel industries, the arms industry should be seen as a commercial determinant of health, where corporate practices matter as much as products when considering how industries can harm health.


Editorial:  Peace dividends in the age of armament 
Jocalyn Clark and Kamran Abbasi urge closer scrutiny of the arms industry at a time when defence spending threatens health

https://www.bmj.com/content/390/bmj.r1794

 

Countering the arms industry as a commercial determinant of health
Mohammed Abba-Aji and Nason Maani outline research, policy, and practice priorities

https://www.bmj.com/content/390/bmj.r1784

 

Analysis:  Weapons, wealth, and health: the arms industry as a commercial determinant of health.
As governments worldwide increase defence spending and arms company revenues climb, we urgently

need to examine how the industry (and not just its products) influences health, argue Mark Bellis and colleagues   https://www.bmj.com/content/390/bmj-2025-086166

 

Weapons of influence: tactics of a growing arms industry and needed health actions
Health professionals must do more to counterbalance the arms industry’s influence on government, media, finance, and science and its damaging effects on human and planetary health, argue Mark Bellis and colleagues   https://www.bmj.com/content/390/bmj-2025-086167

 

Opinion:  War is a global health crisis: community based action can confront it
As defence spending swells at the expense of human security, healthcare professionals must recentre health as a global priority, writes Zahraa Kapasi from Medact

https://www.bmj.com/content/390/bmj.r1820

 

 

 

No comments:

Post a Comment